Repeat DUI Insurance Carriers — Colorado
Free to compare
What Repeat DUI Means for Colorado Insurance Availability
You received your second DUI conviction in Colorado and the national carrier that insured you after your first offense just sent a non-renewal notice. State Farm, Allstate, and Geico routinely decline repeat-DUI applicants outright—no quote, no negotiation. The non-standard market exists specifically for this scenario, but fewer than six carriers in Colorado write policies for drivers with two or more alcohol offenses within seven years.
Colorado's persistent drunk driver statute (C.R.S. § 42-2-132.5) requires a mandatory two-year ignition interlock device on any driving privileges after a second offense. That IID requirement runs concurrent with your SR-22 filing period and changes what carriers are willing to underwrite. The carriers that remain available differ less on premium than on how they handle IID installation coordination, revocation-period policy continuity, and claims processing during your restricted-license phase.
“Carriers differ less on premium than on IID coordination, revocation-period continuity, and claims processing during restricted-license phases.”
See Who Insures Colorado Drivers After a DUI
Get My Colorado DUI Insurance Quote2 years
Colorado IID Requirement After Second DUI
C.R.S. § 42-2-132.5 designates drivers with two or more DUI/DWAI offenses as persistent drunk drivers and mandates a two-year ignition interlock device as a condition of any driving privileges during the revocation period.
C.R.S. § 42-2-132.5 (persistent drunk driver designation)
Why Most Standard Carriers Exit After a Second Offense
Standard-tier carriers use actuarial thresholds tied to repeat-offense recidivism data. A first DUI moves you from preferred to standard tier at most insurers. A second DUI within seven years trips underwriting rules that classify you as uninsurable under their standard policy forms. State Farm, USAA, Geico, and Travelers all maintain hard underwriting stops at two alcohol-related convictions—they will not bind coverage even if you accept a doubled premium.
Non-standard carriers write policies explicitly designed for repeat offenders. Bristol West, Dairyland, The General, National General, and Progressive Non-Standard are the five carriers licensed in Colorado that actively quote drivers with multiple DUI convictions. Each uses a different underwriting model for persistent drunk driver cases, and those differences produce meaningful variation in how your policy behaves during the IID period and revocation window.
The structural issue: Colorado allows early reinstatement with an interlock-restricted license almost immediately after revocation begins, meaning you can legally drive (with restrictions) during what would otherwise be a no-drive period. Carriers that write repeat-DUI policies must decide whether to bind coverage during the revocation itself or only after full reinstatement. That decision determines whether you can insure a vehicle you own but cannot drive, or whether you need a non-owner SR-22 policy until reinstatement completes.
You cannot legally drive in Colorado with a second DUI until an approved ignition interlock device is installed and your early reinstatement / interlock-restricted license is issued by the DMV.
IID Coordination and Policy Binding Timing
The General writes repeat-DUI policies with owned-vehicle or non-owner options and accepts interlock-restricted licenses as valid for underwriting. Their non-owner SR-22 policies cost $70–$100/month, and they will bind owned-vehicle coverage as soon as your IID installation is complete—they require a copy of the IID installation certificate before issuing the policy. Premium range for owned-vehicle policies: $170–$265/month for state minimum liability. The General's claims department treats interlock violations (driving without blowing, failed rolling retest) as policy exclusions—if an incident occurs while the IID records a violation, the claim may be denied even if the vehicle was insured.
Progressive Non-Standard (distinct from Progressive standard-tier policies) writes repeat-DUI coverage in Colorado and offers both owned-vehicle and non-owner SR-22 options. Non-owner policies start at $75/month. Progressive will bind owned-vehicle policies during your revocation period without requiring IID verification first, but your premium reflects the higher risk. Owned-vehicle repeat-DUI policies range $185–$295/month. Progressive's underwriting treats a third DUI differently from a second—if you have three alcohol-related convictions within ten years, expect a 40–60% surcharge on top of the repeat-offender base rate.
National General writes repeat-DUI policies in Colorado but applies stricter underwriting than the four carriers above. They require proof of IID installation and proof of enrollment in Level II alcohol education before binding any policy—owned or non-owner. Non-owner SR-22 policies cost $80–$110/month; owned-vehicle policies range $190–$300/month. National General will not bind coverage if your previous SR-22 lapsed within the last 12 months, meaning if you let an earlier filing drop and triggered a new suspension, you must wait one year from the lapse date before they will quote you.
$95
Colorado DUI Reinstatement Fee
After completing your revocation period, IID requirement, and SR-22 filing duration, Colorado DMV charges a $95 reinstatement fee to restore full driving privileges. This fee is separate from any DMV hearing fees or license reissuance costs.
Colorado DMV reinstatement schedule
Non-Owner Policies During Revocation
If you do not own a vehicle right now but need SR-22 on file to begin the clock on your filing period, a non-owner SR-22 policy satisfies Colorado's requirement. Dairyland, The General, Progressive, and National General all write non-owner policies for repeat-DUI drivers; Bristol West does not. Non-owner policies provide liability coverage when you drive a vehicle you do not own—a rental, a friend's car, a family member's vehicle—but they do not cover a car titled in your name.
The timing advantage: Colorado requires three years of continuous SR-22 filing after a DUI conviction. If you wait until full reinstatement to buy insurance, your three-year clock does not start until that date. If you bind a non-owner policy during your revocation period, the SR-22 clock starts immediately even though you are not driving your own car yet. That strategy shortens the total time you are under SR-22 filing obligation by however many months pass between revocation and reinstatement.
Compare Repeat-DUI Carriers for Your Situation
Your next step depends on whether you own a vehicle now and how soon you can schedule IID installation. If you own a vehicle and your IID appointment is within the next two weeks, request quotes from Bristol West, Dairyland, and Progressive—all three will bind owned-vehicle policies quickly once installation is verified. If you do not own a vehicle or need SR-22 on file before your IID appointment, Dairyland and Progressive offer the fastest non-owner policy binding with no installation verification required. If you have three DUI convictions or a lapsed SR-22 in the last year, start with Dairyland or The General—they apply the fewest additional restrictions for third offenses and prior lapses. Use the comparison tool to request quotes from all available carriers at once and see which underwrites your specific profile.
Carriers That Write Colorado Repeat-DUI Policies
Bristol West writes repeat-DUI policies statewide and coordinates directly with IID vendors for installation verification before binding coverage. They issue SR-22 filings within 24 hours of payment and will bind a standard auto policy during your interlock-restricted license period, meaning you can insure a vehicle you own even if you are still under revocation. Premium range for repeat offenders: typically $180–$280/month for state minimum liability. Bristol West does not offer non-owner policies—if you do not own a vehicle, you cannot bind coverage with them until you purchase or lease one.
Dairyland writes both owned-vehicle and non-owner SR-22 policies for repeat-DUI drivers. Non-owner policies cost $65–$95/month and satisfy Colorado's SR-22 requirement if you do not currently own a car. Dairyland does not require IID verification before binding a non-owner policy, which makes them the fastest option if you need SR-22 on file before your interlock installation appointment. Owned-vehicle policies range $160–$250/month. Dairyland processes claims normally during the interlock-restricted period and does not treat restricted-license incidents differently from post-reinstatement claims.
Get Your Free Quote
Get My Colorado DUI Insurance QuoteFrequently Asked Questions
Can I get car insurance in Colorado with two DUIs?
Yes. Bristol West, Dairyland, The General, Progressive Non-Standard, and National General all write policies for Colorado drivers with two or more DUI convictions. Standard carriers like State Farm and Geico will not quote repeat offenders, but non-standard insurers specialize in this market. You will pay $160–$300/month for owned-vehicle liability coverage depending on the carrier and your driving history.
Do I need SR-22 insurance for a second DUI in Colorado?
Yes. Colorado requires SR-22 filing for three years after any DUI conviction, including second and third offenses. The SR-22 is not a separate insurance policy—it is a certification your insurer files with the DMV proving you carry at least state minimum liability coverage. All five non-standard carriers that write repeat-DUI policies in Colorado will file SR-22 for you.
What is a non-owner SR-22 policy and do I need one?
A non-owner SR-22 policy provides liability coverage when you drive a vehicle you do not own, and it satisfies Colorado's SR-22 filing requirement even if you do not currently have a car. If you sold your vehicle after your DUI arrest or do not plan to own a car during your revocation period, a non-owner policy starts your three-year SR-22 clock immediately. Dairyland, The General, Progressive, and National General all offer non-owner SR-22 policies; costs range $65–$110/month.
How much does car insurance cost after two DUIs in Colorado?
Owned-vehicle liability policies for repeat-DUI drivers in Colorado typically cost $160–$300/month depending on the carrier, your age, vehicle, and county. Non-owner SR-22 policies cost $65–$110/month. Bristol West and Dairyland tend to quote at the lower end of the range for drivers under 40 with no other violations. Progressive and National General quote higher for drivers with three or more offenses or a lapsed SR-22 in the prior year.
Will insurance cover me if I drive during my Colorado license revocation?
Only if you have an interlock-restricted license issued by Colorado DMV and an approved IID installed in the vehicle. Driving during revocation without an interlock-restricted license voids your policy—most carriers exclude coverage for incidents that occur while you are driving illegally. If you have the restricted license and IID, your policy remains active, but some carriers (The General) exclude claims triggered during an IID violation event like a failed rolling retest.
Can I switch insurance carriers during my SR-22 filing period?
Yes, but your SR-22 filing must remain continuous. If you cancel your current policy, your insurer notifies Colorado DMV within 24 hours, and DMV suspends your license immediately. You must have your new carrier file SR-22 before you cancel the old policy. Dairyland, Progressive, and Bristol West all accept mid-term SR-22 transfers—bind the new policy, confirm the new SR-22 is on file with DMV, then cancel the old one.
Do all repeat-DUI insurance companies require ignition interlock verification?
No. Dairyland and Progressive will bind owned-vehicle policies without requiring IID installation proof first, though your premium reflects the added risk. Bristol West and The General require a copy of your IID installation certificate before binding owned-vehicle coverage. Non-owner policies do not require IID verification at any carrier because non-owner policies do not cover a vehicle you own or drive regularly.